The yellow ring inside Greg’s mug survived everything except a good scrub. Every morning I left the brush beside the faucet. Every morning my husband rinsed the mug, declared it clean, and put it upside down where I could admire the evidence.
For eight months, six o’clock meant hot water and a heaping spoon of turmeric before his warehouse shift. He stood at the sink with his tape gun attached to his belt, drinking something that looked like it ought to be used to mark roadworks.
The first jar came from Costco and cost $14. By the time Pam visited, he had bought four. Fifty-six dollars wasn’t a fortune, but I resented every dollar when his hands swelled enough by lunch that his gloves stopped fitting.
His knees made noises on the stairs. He skipped the doctor. When I asked whether his morning drink was helping, he said, “It’s a scam.”
Then he bought more.
His sister Pam came for Sunday dinner. While we were getting things ready, Greg went to the sink and made himself another mug. The six-o’clock habit had acquired an occasional second performance.
Pam took the mug from him. She smelled it, then turned the jar around and read the label.
“Who told you to take it like this?”
Greg pointed at the jar and said the instructions were on it.
I stood beside the counter with the dish brush in my hand. I wanted Pam to persuade him to get help. I also knew what happened when somebody treated my husband like a child: his hearing packed a suitcase and left.
Before either of us could say anything else, Pam tipped the drink down the drain. She carried the jar away from the sink, leaving Greg with his hand still half raised.
The Jar Beside Pam’s Chair
“Bring that back,” Greg said.
Pam had reached the living room. She set the jar beside her chair, but she didn’t sit down.
“I want you to read it properly.”
“I can read.”
“Then show me where it says a heaping spoon in hot water will fix your hands.”
I put down the brush and followed him. The three of us were alone in the house, which was fortunate. Greg could supply enough embarrassment for a larger gathering without inviting anybody.
He picked up the jar and turned it toward the window.
There were ordinary details about the spice. There was no promise about swollen hands, no treatment instruction, and nothing saying that a mug at six in the morning would save him a doctor’s appointment.
He rubbed his thumb across the label.
“I thought that was where I read it.”
Pam folded her arms. I knew that pose. She could turn being correct into a full-contact sport.
“The thing people miss is that curcumin, one of the compounds in turmeric, is poorly absorbed,” she said. “Taking the powder plain in water doesn’t change that. People use black pepper and some fat with it.”
“That’s it?” Greg said. “Pepper?”
“That’s the tip.”
He looked at me as if we had just discovered that his truck needed a teaspoon of cinnamon.
I held out my hand for the jar.
“Before we make him another drink, how much difference does that make to his hands?”
Pam opened her mouth, then stopped.
“I don’t know about his hands.”
That answer did more good than her grand entrance with the mug.
She took out her phone and pulled up the health information she had read. We went through it together, with Greg standing over my shoulder. His finger left a yellow mark on the edge of the screen.
There was a real point underneath Pam’s performance. Curcumin doesn’t dissolve well in water, and the body absorbs relatively little of it when it’s swallowed on its own. Piperine, a substance in black pepper, can increase absorption. Eating turmeric in food containing some fat may help it dissolve and be taken up, too.
But a kitchen pinch of pepper wasn’t the same as a measured amount used in a study. A teaspoon of spice wasn’t the same as a concentrated curcumin product. And absorbing more of something didn’t prove it would relieve whatever was making Greg’s hands swell.
I read that last part twice.
“So I’ve wasted eight months because I didn’t put pepper in?” he said.
“No,” I said. “We can’t say that.”
Pam sat down.
“I made it sound simpler than it is.”
“You poured it away pretty simply.”
“Yes. I did.”
He took the jar from me and held it against his stomach.
I wanted to seize the moment and tell him everything I had swallowed for eight months: that I hated the morning grimace, that I hated hearing him blame getting older, that I hated how quickly he could buy another jar and how slowly he could pick up a telephone.
Instead, I asked Pam to keep reading.
The information didn’t give us a reason to declare turmeric useless. Some research suggests certain turmeric or curcumin preparations may offer modest relief for some people with osteoarthritis symptoms. That was a narrower statement than the promises we’d been talking around.
It didn’t tell us what was wrong with Greg. It didn’t make his swollen hands safe to ignore.
Greg lowered himself onto the sofa.
“Then what exactly have I been doing wrong?”
“Trusting this to do a job nobody established it could do,” I said.
He turned the jar again. I could see him looking for a sentence that would get him out of the room with his pride intact.
Pam leaned forward.
“And I was wrong to grab it. You’re allowed to drink something I wouldn’t drink.”
“Generous of you.”
“But you shouldn’t have to force it down because you think it’s treatment.”
He looked toward the kitchen.
“I didn’t force it.”
“Greg,” I said, “you make the same face afterward that you make when you find a wet sock.”
His mouth twitched. Then he pressed his hands together, and the smile went.
“Some mornings I thought it helped.”
“It might have felt better some mornings,” I said. “You don’t have to defend that. But by lunch you couldn’t get your gloves on.”
He stopped rubbing his fingers.
Pam’s phone was still open between us. I asked her to read the cautions, too, because people always like the promising paragraph and leave the troublesome one for somebody else’s family.
Anyone taking blood thinners or other medicines needed advice before starting turmeric or curcumin supplements, especially products containing piperine. Gallbladder trouble was another reason to ask a clinician first. Concentrated products carried risks that a sprinkle in dinner didn’t necessarily carry in the same way.
Greg gave the jar a small shake.
“So now this is dangerous?”
“No,” Pam said. “We’re saying food and supplements aren’t interchangeable. Neither are all the people taking them.”
He put it on the coffee table.
“Fine. No more water. I’ll put it in dinner.”
I stayed standing.
“And the appointment?”
The Gloves He Couldn’t Wear
Greg leaned back against the sofa.
“Can we have one conversation without it becoming that?”
“This has been that conversation for eight months.”
Pam reached toward the jar, caught herself, and put her hand on her own knee.
I was grateful. One confiscation per Sunday was plenty.
Greg looked between us.
“You both think I’m an idiot.”
“I think you’re hurting,” I said.
“You think I don’t know that?”
He stood so abruptly that I moved aside. He went into the kitchen, and I followed him. Pam came as far as the doorway.
Greg braced his hands against the counter beside the sink. The yellow drink was gone. A little powder remained on the steel, caught around the drain.
“Every time I mention my hands,” he said, “you want to know whether I’ve called. Every time I go up the stairs, you listen.”
I wanted to deny the listening.
I couldn’t.
“Yes,” I said.
“It’s like living with a smoke alarm.”
“Then stop telling the smoke alarm there’s nothing burning.”
Pam made a sound behind me, half a laugh, and Greg turned.
“Don’t.”
She straightened.
“You’re right. Sorry.”
He faced the sink again.
“I’m still working. I still get everything done.”
“With gloves that don’t fit by lunch.”
“I manage.”
“Show Pam.”
He looked at me.
I regretted the words as soon as they left my mouth. He wasn’t a demonstration, and I had just offered him up as one.
“That was unfair,” I said. “You don’t have to show anybody anything.”
For a moment, none of us moved.
Then Greg reached into the pocket of the work jacket hanging by the back door. He brought out his gloves and laid them beside the sink.
He pushed his right hand into one. His fingers went in, but he struggled to settle it over his knuckles. He tugged once at the cuff, then stopped.
Pam looked down at her own hands.
“You work like that?”
“Not every minute.”
“But enough,” she said.
He pulled the glove off and dropped it.
There it was, the part that had never fitted neatly inside a cheerful tip about a kitchen spice. His hand hurt. His work still needed doing. A drink gave him something to try before six-fifteen without asking anybody for time off or admitting he needed help.
I pulled a chair from beside the kitchen wall.
“Sit with me a minute.”
“I’m not falling over.”
“Neither am I, but my feet are tired.”
He sat. I took the other chair. Pam stayed in the doorway until I nodded toward the stool.
Greg stared at the gloves.
“What if they tell me I can’t keep doing the job?”
The question came out so plainly that my prepared argument disappeared.
I had thought he was being stubborn. He was certainly qualified. But I hadn’t asked what he was afraid a doctor might say.
“We don’t know what they’ll tell you,” I said.
“Exactly.”
“We don’t know what waiting will cost you either.”
He rubbed the seam of a glove between his fingers.
“I can’t just stop working.”
“I’m asking you to get examined. I’m not asking you to resign.”
Pam leaned her elbows on her knees.
“I should have asked about this before I started talking about pepper.”
“Yes, you should.”
“I wanted to have the answer.”
“Well, congratulations. You had a drain.”
She accepted that without arguing.
I went to the living room, fetched the turmeric jar, and put it beside Greg’s gloves.
“Here. Yours.”
He touched the lid.
“You’re giving it back?”
“It never belonged to either of us.”
Pam looked at him.
“I’m sorry I poured your drink away. I should have asked.”
He nodded once. She would have to live without a parade.
Then I put my phone beside the jar.
“I want you to call when the office opens tomorrow. I’ll come if you want me. I’ll stay home if you don’t. But I won’t help turn another recipe into a reason to postpone it.”
Greg looked at the phone as though it were a piece of machinery requiring an expensive attachment.
“What do I even say?”
“Say your hands swell enough that your work gloves stop fitting. Say how long it’s been happening.”
“And the knees,” Pam said.
He looked at her.
“Sorry,” she said. “I’ll let you talk.”
He pulled the phone toward him and opened a note. With one finger, slowly, he typed what he wanted to tell the office.
He put in the hand swelling first. Then the trouble with his gloves. Then the knees and the turmeric he’d been taking.
“Put in the heaping spoon,” I said. “They need to know roughly how much.”
“I don’t know how much a heap is.”
“Neither do I. That’s rather the problem with a heap.”
He added it.
Pam asked whether he wanted help finding the office number. He said he had it. She stayed on the stool while he found it himself.
That mattered. We had spent too much of the afternoon reaching for things before he could.
When he finished, he set the phone down.
“Tomorrow morning. I’ll call.”
I wanted to make him swear. I wanted to pin the promise to the refrigerator.
Instead, I asked whether he’d like me beside him.
He picked up the gloves and folded them together.
“Yes.”
The Spoon Went Into Dinner
Pam got up from the stool and asked what still needed doing for dinner.
“Potatoes,” I said.
“I can manage potatoes.”
“Without confiscating them?”
She gave me a look, then took the pan I handed her.
Greg stayed in his chair for another minute. He turned the turmeric jar slowly between his hands.
“Can we still use this stuff?”
“Of course,” I said. “We bought a spice.”
That brought the first real laugh out of him.
Pam had originally suggested about a teaspoon of turmeric, a pinch of black pepper, and a teaspoon of olive oil. We agreed to try that as seasoning for the whole pan of potatoes, not as a daily dose for Greg.
A teaspoon of powder plus a teaspoon of oil wasn’t a medically tested formula. Nor did calling it a two-teaspoon mixture give it special powers. We didn’t need to disguise dinner as a prescription.
Greg measured the turmeric without a heap. Pam added pepper, and I tossed the potatoes with the oil and seasonings.
“Warm food makes more sense to me than oily tea,” I said.
“You could have said something eight months ago.”
“I did. You told me I didn’t appreciate natural flavors.”
“It tasted like a flowerpot.”
“An expensive flowerpot.”
He screwed the lid back onto the jar and put it beside the other spices.
We ate without inspecting his hands between bites. Nobody asked whether he could feel the turmeric working. Pam told a story badly, doubled back twice, and still expected us to admire the ending. For part of the evening, Greg was simply her brother again.
Before she left, she stopped at the back door.
“I’ll ask next time,” she said.
“Good.”
“And no more advice from half an article.”
“Better.”
He held the door for her, and she squeezed his shoulder on the way out.
The next morning at six, I came into the kitchen to find Greg at the sink with his usual mug. His tape gun was on his belt.
For a moment my stomach tightened.
He lifted the mug toward me.
“Coffee.”
I filled my own cup and sat with him while he checked the note on his phone. He had arranged to go in later so he could call when the doctor’s office opened.
“Don’t answer for me,” he said.
“I won’t.”
“If I forget something, you can point.”
I promised to keep my pointing dignified, which was a large commitment before breakfast.
When the office answered, Greg gave his name. Then he read the first line he’d written.
“My hands have been swelling, and by lunchtime my work gloves don’t fit.”
He looked at me. I kept my mouth shut.
He explained the rest and answered their questions. Before he hung up, he had an appointment and instructions about what to do if his symptoms changed before then.
He set the phone down.
“There.”
“Thank you.”
“That sounded too easy for all the fuss.”
“Making the call was easy. You did the difficult bit yesterday.”
He reached for his coffee and said nothing.
At his appointment later that week, I sat beside him because he asked me to. He brought the jar and his list of symptoms, rather than trying to remember everything under fluorescent lights.
The clinician examined him and discussed what needed checking. Greg described the swelling himself. He asked what he could safely do for discomfort while the evaluation continued, and what changes would mean he needed help sooner.
When turmeric came up, he asked the question we’d been circling since Sunday.
“Would taking it with pepper have prevented this?”
The answer was no one could make that claim. Better absorption wasn’t proof that a spice would treat his problem. Persistent swelling needed its own assessment.
Greg nodded and wrote that down.
They also went through medicines and supplements before discussing what was appropriate for him. That included the difference between cooking with turmeric and taking concentrated products. We left without a promise of an overnight cure, but with next steps Greg understood.
In the car, he folded his papers and tucked them into his jacket.
“I should have come sooner.”
“Yes.”
He looked over at me.
“You could soften that.”
“I could.”
He smiled, and I put my hand over his on the seat between us.
We didn’t throw the turmeric away. We didn’t buy a stronger version, either. No capsules arrived promising to succeed where the jar had failed.
The jar stayed with the spices, where Greg could reach it when he cooked. His care stayed with the clinician who had examined him. When his hands bothered him, he told me instead of reporting that the morning drink merely needed more time.
One evening, as we were cleaning up, he took his mug off the shelf and held it under the kitchen light.
“Still yellow.”
“Yes. It’s committed.”
He wet the brush and worked at the ring inside. I reached to take over, then stopped.
“Want me to do that?”
He considered it, then handed me the mug.
“Please.”
I scrubbed while he dried the dishes. When the stain finally lifted, I filled the clean mug with tea and set it in his hands.
He left the tape gun by the door and came to sit beside me.
For another family story about a household remedy raising questions, read My Mother Closed Her Wallet With Her Money Still Inside. For more unexpected family moments, see My Husband Called My Granddaughter the Wrong Kind of Grandchild and My Uncle Gave My Chair Away Under His Own Portrait.