My Sister Put My Foot-Care Jar Beside My Waxing Bill

Lucy Evans

The booking page wanted me to choose a time, and I was trying to decide which part of my week I wanted to spend getting hair pulled out.

Donna leaned against the kitchen counter behind me. She could read a price over somebody’s shoulder from a distance that defeated her when she needed the thermostat.

I was booking my fourth waxing appointment of the year. The salon charged $65 a visit for my upper lip, arms and legs, and I went about every five weeks. By the third week, I was running a hand over my arms and counting how long I had left.

My sister pushed up my sleeve. A thread caught against the stubble on my forearm.

She held the fabric away from my skin, looked at my phone and took it out of my hand.

“That’s close to $700 a year, and you still have hair by week three.”

She had been watching this routine for two years. Apparently, she had been keeping accounts as well. I wanted to tell her that I was buying a service, not a guarantee that my body would retire from growing hair.

Instead, I reached for the phone.

Donna gave it back, but she was already heading toward my bathroom. I followed her with the booking page still open. There were things in that cabinet I hadn’t organized since the last time I confidently bought a new organizing basket.

She opened the door and reached past the toothpaste.

Out came the jar I used on my heels, the one I had bought for my feet and rarely thought about otherwise. She held it up beside her face.

“You’ve been paying for this the whole time.”

The jar with the blue lid

I took the jar from her.

It was plain petroleum jelly. The label said what it had said when I bought it, and nowhere did it offer to put a hair follicle out of business.

“For what, exactly?” I said.

“For keeping your skin soft. You could do this at home.”

“Donna. I’ve been paying to have hair removed.”

She pointed at the jar as if the missing instruction might be printed on the other side.

“You put it on, and then you take the hair off.”

“With what?”

“A razor. Or one of those little trimmers.”

I set the jar on the counter.

“Then the thing taking the hair off would be the razor.”

Donna pulled her mouth to one side. She had worn that expression since childhood, usually when an argument had wandered away from the version she had rehearsed.

“All I’m saying is you don’t need to keep spending that money.”

That was worth talking about. The jar performing a small bathroom miracle was not.

I liked petroleum jelly. It helped my heels feel less like they belonged on a garden rake. But I wasn’t about to spread it over my upper lip on the strength of my sister holding it confidently.

“Does this remove hair?” I said.

“No. Not by itself.”

“Does it stop the hair growing?”

“No.”

“Then you led with quite a sentence.”

She laughed. I didn’t, and she stopped.

I was still holding the phone. The salon’s page had gone dark, and my own face looked back at me from the screen. I pressed the side button and opened a search instead.

We stayed in the bathroom while I checked guidance from dermatology organizations. Donna stood beside me, close enough to read, which was suddenly less amusing than it had been in the kitchen.

There was no good evidence that petroleum jelly removed hair or stopped its growth. Its job was to help hold moisture in the skin. For someone who tolerated it, a thin layer could help dry skin feel more comfortable. It wasn’t a substitute for a hair-removal method.

That distinction took less than a minute to find.

“Well, I didn’t say it melted the hair,” Donna said.

“You took my phone and brought me to a jar.”

She folded her arms.

I went on reading.

Shaving cut hair at the surface. Trimming shortened it. Neither reached the part beneath the skin that produced new growth. Waxing pulled hairs out, but it didn’t reliably stop them returning either.

So there were cheaper ways to manage the hair. There was no cheap jar in my cabinet that would make it disappear permanently.

I said that out loud, because I needed to hear a whole sentence without a sales pitch hanging off the end.

Donna nodded.

“And shaving doesn’t make it grow back thicker,” she said.

I checked that too.

She was right about that part. A cut hair could feel rougher because of its blunt end, but shaving didn’t change its thickness, color or rate of growth.

“One point to Donna,” I said.

“I’ll take it.”

I put the phone down before she could turn one point into a championship.

The bathroom had no audience but the two of us. Even so, I felt foolish. For a few seconds, while she carried that jar out of the cabinet, I had wanted her to be right.

I wanted something inexpensive and painless that I could do once and forget. I wanted to stop arranging sleeves and appointments around a perfectly ordinary thing my body did.

I hadn’t said any of that in the kitchen.

Donna reached toward my arm.

“Don’t,” I said.

Her hand stopped.

“The sleeve thing. Don’t do that again.”

“I was showing you.”

“I live inside the arm. I’ve seen it.”

She let her hand fall.

The laugh came out of me then, but it was a small one. I wasn’t ready to make her comfortable yet.

She looked at the jar on the counter.

“I should have said there were cheaper options.”

“Yes.”

“And asked whether you wanted to hear them.”

“That would have been a strong opening.”

My sister could be generous with her time and reckless with a conclusion. Usually I smoothed the second part over because of the first. This time, I left the silence where it was.

Finally, she said, “I’m sorry I made it sound as if you’d been stupid.”

I picked up my phone again.

The appointment was still unbooked. I hadn’t paid a deposit. All I had done was select the service, which meant I could close the page without canceling anything or explaining myself.

But I didn’t close it yet.

“I want to know what I’m choosing before somebody chooses for me,” I said.

Donna pulled the little bathroom stool away from the wall.

“Then let’s look.”

The appointment I hadn’t booked

I sat on the closed toilet lid while Donna took the stool. We looked ridiculous, holding a consultation between the towel rail and a wastebasket that needed emptying.

At least no one was charging $65 for it.

I began with the thing I wanted, rather than the thing my sister wanted me to stop doing.

“I don’t want to hurt my skin,” I said. “I don’t want another expensive routine. And I don’t want to spend every morning inspecting myself.”

Donna started to answer, then pressed her lips together.

“Go on,” she said.

“The upper lip bothers me. My legs bother me sometimes. My arms mostly bother me when somebody starts handling my sleeves.”

She looked down.

“Fair.”

That was the first useful division we’d made. The salon offered the three areas as one visit. I had begun treating them as one obligation.

They weren’t.

I could leave my arms alone. I could choose to trim my upper lip. I could shave my legs when I felt like it, or keep waxing if I decided the result was worth the price.

The bathroom mirror did not require me to submit one policy covering all exposed skin.

Donna held out her hand for the phone.

“May I?”

I gave it to her.

We read about electric facial trimmers first. They cut close to the skin, though not necessarily as close as a blade. They could be convenient, but they still needed cleaning and could still irritate skin. The instructions for the particular device mattered.

There was no promise of weeks without regrowth. On the other hand, I could use one at home without waiting for hair to reach the length needed for waxing.

“That sounds closer to what I want,” I said.

“For your lip?”

“For my lip. My arms are being released from service.”

Donna smiled, then checked my face before allowing herself the whole smile.

For legs, we looked at shaving guidance. Warm water, a suitable shaving gel or cream, a clean sharp blade and light pressure. Shaving with the direction of growth could help reduce irritation. Rinsing the blade and avoiding repeated passes over one patch mattered more than racing to get everything perfectly smooth.

I had shaved before. What I needed was permission to consider it an ordinary choice again, rather than evidence that I had failed to maintain myself properly.

I didn’t need that permission from Donna.

“Can I use the jar for shaving?” I said.

“I thought so.”

We checked rather than letting that sentence do the work.

Petroleum jelly wasn’t necessary, and a product made for shaving was generally a more practical choice. A thick layer could clog a razor and make things slippery. The jar could stay what it had always been: a moisturizer for dry areas, used sparingly on skin that tolerated it.

I turned the lid until it clicked shut.

“Your promotion has been canceled,” I told it.

Donna laughed hard enough to bend forward on the stool.

Then I asked about longer-lasting options.

This was where the word “permanent” needed care. Electrolysis could permanently remove treated hairs by destroying individual follicles, but it required a trained practitioner and repeated sessions. It could take time and cost money, especially over larger areas.

Laser treatments generally offered long-term hair reduction rather than a guarantee that every hair would be gone forever. Results depended on hair pigment, skin tone, the equipment and the practitioner’s skill. Maintenance could be needed. Light, gray or white hair usually responded poorly to laser.

We read that last part twice.

I had enough pale hairs mixed in to know that a glowing advertisement might not be describing my particular upper lip.

“That’s a consultation, then,” Donna said.

“If I want one.”

“If you want one.”

At-home light devices weren’t the same thing as a household moisturizer, either. They had limits, suitability warnings and instructions that mattered. I didn’t intend to buy one while sitting beside the toilet just because I was irritated with my waxing bill.

One impulsive bathroom decision was plenty for the afternoon.

I asked Donna to open the calculator.

At $65 every five weeks, the routine worked out to roughly $676 over a full year. The actual total depended on how appointments fell and whether I skipped one. Her “close to $700” was fair.

But the fourth visit hadn’t happened. I had paid for three appointments that year, totaling $195. Closing the booking page would avoid the next $65 charge; it wouldn’t put $700 into my hand.

“Put that part in your speech next time,” I said.

She turned the phone toward me.

“I’m not giving that speech again.”

“You might. You’re fond of a number with an audience.”

“There isn’t an audience.”

“There’s me.”

She lowered the phone.

For the first time that afternoon, she didn’t have an answer ready.

I wasn’t angry about the arithmetic. I was angry that she had turned an expense I was already tired of into a demonstration of how foolish I had been.

My salon had done what I booked. Waxing was temporary. The hair growing back wasn’t proof that anyone had cheated me.

And my sister knowing a cheaper option didn’t give her ownership of my arm.

I held out my hand. She put the phone in it.

“Before I decide,” I said, “we need to finish the part where you took this.”

Donna put the phone back

Donna sat straight on the stool.

“I was trying to save you money.”

“I know.”

“You were about to book again. You told me the last appointment hurt. I thought, if I stopped you for a second, you’d listen.”

“I was standing beside you. You could have spoken.”

She rubbed her palms against her trousers.

“I got carried away.”

“You made a moisturizer sound like a treatment.”

“I knew you would still have to remove the hair.”

“I didn’t know what you knew. You were holding up a jar and telling me I’d been paying for it.”

She looked toward the cabinet, then back at me.

“I wanted you to see that you had other choices.”

That much, I believed. I loved my sister. I didn’t need to turn her into a monster to tell her she had behaved badly.

But she was also accustomed to being the person who found the bargain, knew the shortcut and delivered the answer. Letting go of that position made her fidget more than an apology did.

She started again.

“You’ve spent two years doing something you complain about, and I hate seeing you unhappy over it. Every time you’re waiting for another appointment, you talk about the hair. I thought I could get you out of the whole thing.”

“With petroleum jelly?”

Her face tightened.

“No,” she said. “Not with petroleum jelly.”

She reached for the jar, then left her hand beside it instead.

“I got that wrong. It won’t remove your hair. It won’t stop it growing. I shouldn’t have implied it would.”

The room went quiet.

There it was, without a joke to soften it or a “but” to take it back.

I hadn’t needed a grand confession. I needed my sister to stop defending the sentence long enough to correct it.

“And the phone?” I said.

“I shouldn’t have taken it.”

“And my sleeve?”

She looked at my forearm.

“I won’t do that again.”

I nodded.

Donna’s eyes filled, which annoyed her immediately. She pressed a finger beneath one eye and looked at the ceiling.

“I hate that I made you feel small.”

“I hate that you thought I needed to feel small before I’d listen.”

She took that one without arguing.

I could have kept going. There were other times I could have dragged into that bathroom. Sisters maintain a frightening archive, much of it indexed by clothing.

I left the archive shut.

She had answered what happened that afternoon. That was the thing in front of us.

I opened the booking page and closed it.

Donna kept her hands in her lap.

“What are you going to do?” she said.

“Buy a facial trimmer after I’ve read the instructions and reviews. Try shaving my legs again when I want to. Leave my arms alone.”

“And if you don’t like it?”

“I can choose something else.”

“Even waxing.”

“Even waxing.”

She nodded.

The money had become simpler once I stopped asking one decision to settle the rest of my life. I would avoid the unbooked $65 visit. I would spend something on a trimmer, so the savings wouldn’t be the whole amount. If it suited me, I could stop paying for appointments I no longer wanted.

No permanent result had appeared in my bathroom. A manageable routine might.

That was enough to begin with.

Before we got up, I checked one more thing. We had read that new, rapid or marked changes in facial or body hair could sometimes deserve medical attention, particularly alongside other symptoms. Hair changes around menopause could be common, but a sudden change shouldn’t automatically be treated as a grooming problem.

My concern was the familiar regrowth after waxing, not a sudden new pattern. Still, I was glad we’d checked instead of putting every possible question under a lid labeled “beauty.”

Donna stood and pushed the stool back against the wall.

“Would you like me to come with you to look at trimmers?”

I considered saying no just to make a point. The point had already been made.

“Yes,” I said. “You can carry the basket.”

She put a hand to her chest.

“A position of enormous responsibility.”

“Don’t let it go to your head.”

We left the bathroom together. I carried the jar back to its shelf first.

On our shopping trip, Donna handed me two boxes and waited while I read them. No snatching, no declaration that one had changed a stranger’s life. I chose a simple facial trimmer intended for that area and kept the instructions.

At home, I cleaned it as directed and tried it on a small area first. My skin tolerated it. When I used it on my upper lip later, I took my time.

The result wasn’t the bare-skin feel I sometimes got from waxing, and I knew the hair would return. I could manage that without booking another appointment.

I left my arms alone.

The first time I reached for a short-sleeved top afterward, I almost chose something else. Then I put it on and went about my day. Nobody stopped me in the street to demand an explanation for my forearms.

A week later, Donna came over while I was putting hand towels away. She stayed at the bathroom door until I waved her in.

“How’s the trimmer?” she said.

“Useful. Not enchanted.”

“Unlike the foot jar.”

“The foot jar has accepted its limitations.”

She laughed, and this time there was no sore place underneath it.

I opened the cabinet to put away a clean washcloth. The trimmer was on its own shelf, dry and stored according to its instructions. The petroleum jelly stood where it had before, ready for my heels.

Donna picked up the jar, then paused.

“May I?”

I held out my hand.

She placed it in my palm and closed my fingers around it.

“For your feet,” she said.

I screwed off the lid and nudged the stool toward her with my toe.

“Stay a minute, Donna.”

For more stories about everyday remedies with unexpected claims, read the bedtime teaspoon seed story and what happened when garlic caused a burn. And for a much darker family confrontation, there’s the six days of pills left in a purse.