My Husband Let Pam Choose My Wedding Picture

Sofia Rossi

The silver sandals were still beside the bathtub when Joyce called. I couldn’t bear to put them back in their box. I couldn’t bear to look at them, either.

At sixty-three, after thirty years behind a post office counter, I knew my feet weren’t going into a jewelry advertisement. But I’d bought those shoes for my son Kevin’s wedding, and for once I’d wanted to feel pretty.

At the reception, my sister-in-law Pam pointed down.

“Did you walk here barefoot, Donna?”

Kevin’s new in-laws heard. Pam laughed, and my husband, Steve, went on cutting his chicken. I tucked my feet beneath my chair and stayed there when I should have been dancing with my son.

Back home, I sat on the tub’s edge and attacked my heels with a pumice stone. By the time I stopped, they stung worse than before.

Joyce rang at seven the next morning. Steve’s mother was eighty-eight, and apparently her son could discuss an insult afterward more easily than interrupt one.

She told me she’d raised Pam’s mother’s whole family on Delancey Street and hadn’t heard a kind word about anybody’s body from them.

On her instructions, I found the petroleum jelly behind the drain cleaner under the bathroom sink. Its lid was crusted. Joyce recommended a thin layer and cotton socks at bedtime, crediting that routine with keeping her heels soft since she’d left the Woolworth’s counter in 1976.

I tried it while she waited, one foot on the toilet lid. I also promised to call Dr. Nguyen if the skin opened, bled, or my blood sugar became a concern.

Her fourth household use involved the front door lock in January. That sent me toward Steve.

He was at the kitchen counter, wedding pictures open on his laptop.

“Don’t,” he said. “Pam asked me to tell you the shoe picture is going in the family album. Your feet are in it.”

The Picture on Steve’s Screen

I stopped with one sock half twisted beneath my foot.

“I came to ask about the lock.”

Steve looked past me toward the bathroom, as if another wife might emerge with a less troublesome subject.

“What lock?”

“Your mother says she puts a little petroleum jelly on hers in winter. You always tell me nothing greasy belongs inside it.”

“Nothing greasy does belong inside it.”

For thirty-eight years, I’d heard his lecture about that lock. I’d walked down the hallway prepared to enjoy finding him wrong about something small. Instead, he’d offered me something enormous before I could open my mouth.

As it happened, he was right about the lock. We checked its care instructions later: use the recommended lock lubricant, not petroleum jelly that could collect dirt inside the mechanism. Joyce’s household advice came with confidence rather than a manufacturer’s warranty.

But that morning I pulled out the stool beside Steve.

“Show me the picture.”

“It’s just a picture, Donna.”

“Then showing me should be easy.”

He turned the laptop.

The photographer had sent a few preview photographs. In this one, the bride’s shoes, her mother’s shoes, and my silver sandals appeared beneath our dress hems. My feet were turned sideways. You could see the rough skin on my heels.

You could also see the bride’s hand resting on my wrist. I’d forgotten that part.

Pam had sent Steve a message beneath the image.

Make sure this one gets into the family album. Donna will love the barefoot reminder.

I read it twice. Steve reached toward the trackpad.

“Leave it.”

“She thinks she’s being funny.”

“What did you tell her?”

He rubbed a thumb along the counter. There was a crumb beneath it. Apparently the crumb needed his complete attention.

“Nothing yet.”

“Then why did you say ‘don’t’ when I came in?”

“Because I knew you’d get upset.”

I wanted to shut the laptop so hard his chicken from the night before would jump. Instead, I put both hands on my knees.

“Kevin asked me to dance. I told him my feet hurt.”

“They did hurt.”

“After I scrubbed them raw. Before that, I was ashamed.”

Steve turned toward me then.

“He thought you were tired.”

“I let him think that.”

The missed dance sat between us. No cream in the bathroom cabinet could put me back in that room when my son held out his hand.

From down the hall came Joyce’s voice.

“Donna? Are you still there?”

I’d left my phone on the bathroom counter with the call connected. At eighty-eight, Joyce could project through a hallway better than our smoke alarm.

I fetched it and put it on speaker beside the laptop.

“Steve’s here,” I said.

“Good. Did he apologize?”

Steve sat up.

“Mom.”

“That isn’t an apology. That’s my name.”

He glanced at me, waiting for the little smile I usually supplied when his mother got after him. I didn’t have one available.

“Pam sent him a message about putting the shoe photograph in the album,” I said. “She called it a barefoot reminder.”

Joyce went quiet.

Then she said, “Read me what he wrote back.”

“He hasn’t.”

Steve pushed the laptop an inch away.

“I haven’t answered because I don’t want to make a thing out of it.”

Joyce said, “Your wife is standing in the bathroom rubbing her feet sore. There’s your thing.”

I sat down again. My sock seam pressed against my heel, and I shifted it with my toe.

“Who is choosing the family album?” I asked.

“Pam offered to help put one together for us,” Steve said. “She’s good at that sort of thing.”

Pam liked being the person who arranged everybody. At family photographs she could move a grown man three feet to the left with one finger. I’d mistaken that for usefulness for years.

“I don’t want her choosing pictures of me.”

“Fine. I’ll tell her to use a different one.”

“No. Tell her why.”

He blew out a breath.

“She’s coming over this afternoon anyway. She wants us to pick favorites before Kevin and his wife leave tomorrow.”

“Then tell her when she gets here.”

He looked at the phone.

“Mom, can you help me out?”

“I am.”

I almost laughed. It came out as a cough.

Steve lowered his head. For the first time that morning, he looked at the socks instead of the laptop.

“I should have said something at the wedding.”

“Yes.”

“I didn’t think—”

“Yes,” I said again.

Joyce asked him to pick her up before Pam arrived. She didn’t ask whether that would be convenient.

After we ended the call, Steve reached for my hand.

I let him hold it, but I didn’t squeeze back.

“I want Kevin here,” I said.

“He shouldn’t have to deal with this the day after his wedding.”

I pulled my hand away.

“Then we ought to have dealt with it at his wedding.”

Pam’s Favorite

Steve left to collect Joyce while I called Kevin.

I kept the call short. I asked him and his wife to come over before Pam arrived, and I told him I needed to explain why I’d missed our dance.

“Are you hurt?” he said.

“Not the way you mean.”

He said they’d come.

While I waited, I washed the pumice stone and put it away. My heels were irritated, so I left them alone rather than trying another remedy. The jar went on a shelf away from the drain cleaner. I wiped its outside and checked the label before deciding whether it was worth keeping.

There was something ridiculous about doing housekeeping in the middle of being furious. Apparently I could demand respect and still be bothered by a sticky lid.

Kevin and his wife arrived first. She carried her wedding shoes in a bag because she’d thought we might want another photograph of them.

That nearly finished me.

“I thought we could do one without all the dress fabric,” she said. “You could hardly see your sandals.”

I took the bag from her and set it on the hall bench.

“Before we do anything, I owe you both an explanation.”

Kevin stayed standing. His wife sat beside me.

I told them what Pam had said. I told them about the message on Steve’s laptop. When I reached the dance, my mouth wouldn’t cooperate.

Kevin crouched in front of my chair.

“Mom. I would have danced with you in slippers.”

“I know.”

“You said you wanted to sit.”

“I know.”

He put his forehead against my hand for a second. He’d done that as a boy when he wanted comforting without admitting it.

His wife wiped her eyes with her sleeve.

“I asked for that shoe picture,” she said. “I’m so sorry.”

“Don’t you apologize for asking me to stand beside you.”

She nodded, but she stayed close enough that our shoulders touched.

Steve brought Joyce in a few minutes later. Joyce took one look at Kevin on the floor and gripped Steve’s arm harder.

“Get me a chair where I can hear.”

There were six of us in the living room when Pam arrived: me, Steve, Joyce, Kevin, his wife, and Pam herself.

Pam carried her phone and came in talking about album layouts.

“I found a place that does beautiful covers. Not those shiny things that peel at the corners. Steve, did you show Donna my favorite?”

“I saw it,” I said.

She stopped beside the sofa.

“Oh. Good.”

Nobody moved to make room for her.

I hadn’t arranged that. Still, I enjoyed it more than I should have.

“Your message said I’d love the barefoot reminder,” I said. “What did you mean?”

Pam looked at Steve.

“Oh, for heaven’s sake. It was a joke from last night.”

“I remember last night. Explain the joke.”

“Donna, don’t do this. Everybody was laughing and having a lovely time.”

“I wasn’t laughing,” Kevin said.

“You weren’t even sitting there.”

“Exactly. I didn’t know.”

Pam shifted the phone from one hand to the other.

“Well, it wasn’t directed at you.”

His wife sat forward.

“It was directed at my husband’s mother at our wedding.”

Pam gave her the patient smile she used when someone younger disagreed with her.

“You’ll get used to our family. We tease.”

Joyce’s cane hit the floor once.

“Leave her out of your excuse.”

Pam’s smile disappeared.

“I haven’t even sat down, and apparently I’m on trial.”

“You can sit,” I said.

She took the armchair nearest the door. Nobody rushed to reassure her. Her phone stayed upright in her hand, ready to show us lovely covers for an album she had already spoiled.

Steve sat beside me.

“I showed Donna your message this morning,” he said. “I should have answered it when it came.”

“Answered what? I suggested a photograph.”

“You suggested using it to embarrass her.”

“Oh, now you’re offended too.”

“I should have been offended yesterday.”

Pam gave a short laugh.

“Honestly, Steve. You were right there.”

“I know.”

That stopped her longer than any argument would have.

Then she turned to me.

“If your heels were bothering you, why wear those shoes? You could have worn something closed.”

I felt myself reaching for an answer. They matched my dress. They fit. I’d wanted them. Even then, I was prepared to submit a small defense of my footwear to a woman sitting in my living room.

Kevin stood.

“She doesn’t have to explain her shoes.”

“Will you let your mother speak?”

“I asked her to dance,” he said. “She wouldn’t get up. Do you understand what you’re making jokes about?”

Pam looked down at her phone.

“I didn’t tell her not to dance.”

“No,” I said. “You just made getting out of my chair feel impossible.”

My eyes filled. I hated that part. Pam always treated tears like someone bringing an unfair extra person into an argument.

She set her phone on her knee.

“I can’t be responsible for every insecurity somebody has.”

Steve stood up beside Kevin.

“You can be responsible for what you said.”

The Sandals Came Out of the Bathroom

Pam pressed her lips together, then turned toward Joyce.

“Are you going to let them speak to me like this?”

Joyce adjusted the handle of her cane.

“Yes.”

“I’ve spent all morning looking at albums for this family.”

“Nobody asked you to spend the morning insulting Donna,” Joyce said.

“I offered to do something nice.”

“You can stop now,” Steve said.

Pam’s head came up.

“What does that mean?”

“It means you aren’t choosing our album.”

She looked at me as though I’d reached across the room and taken something from her.

“Fine. Do it yourselves. I certainly don’t need the work.”

“Send Steve anything you already gathered,” I said. “Then leave the photographs to us.”

Pam picked up her phone.

“Well, I hope you’re all happy with how this visit has gone.”

Kevin didn’t move away from the door.

“Before you leave, you owe my mother an apology.”

For a moment I thought she might push past him. Then she looked at his wife. Pam liked being the aunt who knew how weddings ought to be done. She’d been explaining napkin arrangements and photograph orders for weeks.

Now the bride wouldn’t even meet her little smile.

Pam faced me.

“I’m sorry you were upset.”

“No,” Steve said.

She stood.

“What do you want me to say? That I deliberately ruined the wedding? That I sat there planning to hurt her? I made one remark. People make remarks. Nobody can open their mouth anymore without somebody deciding it means something awful.”

I let her finish.

Her phone shook slightly in her hand.

“What you said was cruel,” I said. “Then you wanted to put it in an album so I could keep remembering it.”

“I didn’t think you’d take it that way.”

“You know now.”

The room stayed quiet.

Pam glanced around for help. Steve kept his hands at his sides. Joyce sat with her chin lifted. Kevin’s wife took my hand.

At last Pam said, “I’m sorry I said that about your feet.”

I waited.

“And I shouldn’t have sent the message.”

“Thank you,” I said.

She reached for her bag.

“We aren’t carrying the joke into the album,” I added. “Or into the next visit.”

“All right.”

Steve walked her to the door. She tried once more with him, speaking low enough that perhaps she thought we couldn’t hear.

“You could have called me first.”

“I could have stopped you yesterday,” he said.

He opened the door.

When he came back, he didn’t sit down.

“I owe you an apology in front of everybody too.”

My first impulse was to save him from it. Thirty-eight years of being married to a man gives you some foolish reflexes.

I kept my mouth shut.

“You looked at me after Pam said it,” he said. “I remember. I kept eating because I didn’t want an argument.”

Joyce’s eyes closed.

Steve swallowed.

“Then this morning I tried to make you promise there wouldn’t be one. I made this harder for you twice.”

“Yes,” I said.

“I’m sorry.”

He didn’t ask whether we were all right now. That helped.

Kevin put a hand on his shoulder, then looked at me.

“Can we see the photograph?”

Steve brought the laptop into the living room and opened it on his knees. We gathered close enough to see without anyone having to stand behind anybody else.

There were my heels. There was the bride’s hand.

Her thumb had caught the edge of my bracelet. I remembered her saying she liked it, and telling her Kevin’s father had given it to me years ago.

“I don’t want this one gone,” she said. “But it’s your choice.”

I studied it.

The dress hems were crooked. One of my sandal straps had slipped. Her mother had one foot half out of her shoe because she was tired.

We looked like women who had spent a whole day standing up for people we loved.

“Keep it,” I said.

Kevin looked at me.

“Are you sure?”

“Yes. Use the whole picture. No little circles around my heels. No captions supplied by Pam.”

His wife laughed, then pressed her face against my shoulder.

Steve moved the photograph into the folder for our album. Then he closed Pam’s message.

Joyce reached for my hand.

“How are those feet?”

“Sore from my own foolishness.”

“Then no more scrubbing.”

“No more scrubbing.”

We agreed that broken skin, bleeding, persistent itching, or signs of infection meant a call to Dr. Nguyen, and that diabetes or poor circulation would make home foot experiments a bad idea. Cotton socks were comfortable; they weren’t a cure for everything.

“And the lock?” Steve said.

Joyce looked at him over her glasses.

“Apparently your mother can be wrong.”

“Should I get that in writing?”

“You should enjoy it quietly.”

I laughed properly then.

Kevin’s wife went to the hall bench and took out her wedding shoes.

“We still have these,” she said.

Kevin held out his hand to me.

“And we still have music.”

Steve moved the chair back. Joyce tucked her cane against the sofa. I went to the bathroom, picked up the silver sandals, and brought them into the living room.

I set them beside the bride’s shoes.

Then I turned toward my son in my cotton socks.

“These are my dancing shoes today.”

He started the song on his phone, put an arm around me, and waited while I found my balance.

This time, I took his hand and stepped forward.

Family tensions can spill into the most painful moments, as these stories show: a father who sent his grandson outside without his coat, a sister left without even a spoon for dinner, and a husband who turned up the golf while his wife scrubbed.